Posts

Mathematics in ancient Egypt: Wall painting from tomb of Menna 1549 BCE and a short article on Ancient Egyptian land surveying

Mathematics in ancient Egypt: Wall painting from tomb of Menna 1549 BCE and a short article on Ancient Egyptian land surveying Looking closely at the wall painting from the Tomb of Menna, it’s clear that this is a scene of intense administration. I noticed men holding long rods (which the article tells us are measuring rods), scribes sitting cross-legged taking notes, and people bringing in harvest goods. It is a visual record of land management and taxation. After reading the article "Surveying in Ancient Egypt" by Hans Barnard, I have a much better understanding of just how crucial this daily math was to the survival of the civilization. One Thing That Surprised Me: The Math Behind the "Remen" The biggest surprise for me was the invention of the  remen . I knew the Egyptians used cubits (based on the length from the elbow to the middle finger), but I didn't know they had a unit specifically designed to handle irrational numbers. The  remen  was defined as half...

Individual Reflection (Ancient V/S Modern Math)

Individual Reflection   (Ancient V/S Modern Math) Working on this project taught me that math history is not just a list of names and dates, it is a way of thinking. When I first saw the Babylonian method, I thought it was just an old version of the quadratic formula. But as we worked through the problem, I realized it was a completely different approach. The Babylonians did not have variables or equations. They had words, diagrams, and a deep understanding of how shapes fit together. Their "cut-and-paste" method for solving quadratics was visual and concrete. It made me see that algebra is not the only way to do algebra. The most challenging part was the extension. We tried to find a similar relationship for the 7-24-25 triangle, and at first it did not work. We had to figure out why the fractions 1/2 and 1/3 worked for 3-4-5 but not for other triangles. That led us to the general formula for the coefficients, and it was exciting to discover that the pattern we found was jus...

Ancient V/S Modern Math

Our group chose Problem 1.2.4 for Assignment 1. This problem comes from a Seleucid-era clay tablet known as BM 34568, which scholars believe was composed for teaching purposes. The problem describes a rectangle with sides a = 4 and b = 3, and gives the diagonal relationships d = a/2 + b and d = b/3 + a. It then asks us to find a, b, and d using the quantities a + d, b + d, a - b, and the area A = a * b = 12. Part (a) asks for a modern solution. Part (b) asks us to retrace the Babylonian steps using the identity (a + b)^2 - 4A = (a - b)^2, which was passed down to us on clay tablets. The Modern Solution (Part a) The problem is really two questions, each with two parts. From the tablet's rectangle (a = 4, b = 3, d = 5), the given quantities are a + d = 9, b + d = 8, a + b = 7, a - b = 1 and A = ab = 12. Task 1.1: find a and d from a + d and b Task 1.2: find b and d from b + d and a Task 2.1: find a and b from a + b and A Task 2.2: find a and b from a - b and A Task 1.1: using a + d =...
 The Market Scales Puzzle At first I thought the four weights would be 1, 2, 4, 8. That’s the usual doubling pattern. But then I remembered this is a two-pan scale, so you can put weights on both sides. That means you can subtract as well as add. So the weights are 1, 3, 9, 27 . Why? Because with these four weights, you can make every number from 1 to 40 by putting some weights on one pan and some on the other. For example: - 2 = 3 - 1 - 5 = 9 - 3 - 1 - 40 = 27 + 9 + 3 + 1 This works because every number from -40 to 40 can be written as a sum of ±1, ±3, ±9, ±27. It’s called balanced ternary,  base 3, but the digits are -1, 0, and 1 instead of 0, 1, 2. For a one-pan scale , you can only add weights, not subtract them. Then you need 1, 2, 4, 8, 16 . These are powers of 2. With five weights, you can make every number from 1 to 31 by using each weight either once or not at all. That’s just binary representation. For example, 13 = 8 + 4 + 1. This connects to ancient Egyptian multip...
  Did Mesopotamian Scribes Have Algebra? (And How Can We Recognize 'Rhetorical' and 'Syncopated' Algebra?) Yes, Babylonian scribes had algebra, but not the kind we use today. They had  rhetorical algebra , which means everything was written out in words, with no symbols for unknowns or operations. A problem might say: “I have subtracted the side of the square from the area, and the result is 14,30.” We would write that as  x 2 − x = 870 x^2 − x = 870 . The scribes solved quadratic equations using step-by-step verbal recipes: halve the coefficient, square it, add, take the square root. The method was general, but the generality lived in the procedure, not in a formula.  Later, Diophantus used  syncopated algebra,  a middle stage with abbreviations for common quantities and operations. The Babylonians stayed rhetorical. This raises big questions: How do you state a general principle without symbols? By repeating the same procedure with different numbers and d...
 Here is my Babylonian-style base-60 multiplication table for 45. I use commas to separate sexagesimal places. So 22,30 means 22 + 30/60, and 5,37,30 means 5 + 37/60 + 30/3600. Sexagesimal Factorization: Base-60 Factor Pairs for 45 I found these five pairs that multiply to 45 (not using 1): - 3 X 15 = 45 - 4 X 11,15 = 45     Check: 11,15 = 11 + 15/60 = 11.25, and 4 X 11.25 = 45 - 5 X 9 = 45 - 6 X 7,30 = 45     Check: 7,30 = 7 + 30/60 = 7.5, and 6 X 7.5 = 45 - 8 X 5,37,30 = 45     Check: 5,37,30 = 5 + 37/60 + 30/3600 = 5.625, and 8 X 5.625 = 45 So, including the example 2 X 22,30 = 45, there are at least six pairs that work. Three of my new pairs include base-60 fractions. This was a good way to practice thinking in base 60 and to see how fractions work in a sexagesimal place-value system.
  Why Teach Math History? My First Response Before reading Tzanakis and Arcavi’s survey, I thought of math history as mostly enrichment. I imagined names, dates, and fun facts, maybe a short story about Pythagoras or a poster of ancient numerals. I did not see it as central to actually teaching mathematics. I also worried that adding history would take time away from an already packed curriculum, and I was not sure how I would assess it. If I used history at all, I assumed it would be as a hook or a break from the “real” math, not as a serious teaching approach. Several things in the article made me stop and think. First, the authors honestly list the common objections, history is not math, there is not enough time, resources, or teacher expertise, and assessment is unclear. I appreciated that they did not just cheerlead for history. Second, I was surprised by the idea of a “genetic” or history-inspired approach: using the historical development of an idea to design a sequence of p...