Ancient V/S Modern Math
Our group chose Problem 1.2.4 for Assignment 1. This problem comes from a Seleucid-era clay tablet known as BM 34568, which scholars believe was composed for teaching purposes. The problem describes a rectangle with sides a = 4 and b = 3, and gives the diagonal relationships d = a/2 + b and d = b/3 + a. It then asks us to find a, b, and d using the quantities a + d, b + d, a - b, and the area A = a * b = 12. Part (a) asks for a modern solution. Part (b) asks us to retrace the Babylonian steps using the identity
(a + b)^2 - 4A = (a - b)^2,
which was passed down to us on clay tablets.
The Modern Solution (Part a)
The problem is really two questions, each with two parts. From the tablet's rectangle (a = 4, b = 3, d = 5), the given quantities are a + d = 9, b + d = 8, a + b = 7, a - b = 1 and A = ab = 12.
Task 1.1: find a and d from a + d and b
Task 1.2: find b and d from b + d and a
Task 2.1: find a and b from a + b and A
Task 2.2: find a and b from a - b and A
Task 1.1: using a + d = 9 and b = 3
1. Set up the binomial formula: (a + d)^2 = a^2 + 2ad + d^2
2. Subtract b^2 from both sides: (a + d)^2 - b^2 = a^2 + 2ad + d^2 - b^2
3. Use the Pythagorean relation (d^2 - b^2 = a^2): (a + d)^2 - b^2 = a^2 + 2ad + a^2 = 2a^2 + 2ad = 2a(a + d)
4. Solve for a: a = ((a + d)^2 - b^2) / (2(a + d))
5. Substitute the given values (a + d = 9 and b = 3): a = (9^2 - 3^2) / (2 * 9) = (81 - 9) / 18 = 72 / 18 = 4
6. Find the diagonal d: d = (a + d) - a = 9 - 4 = 5
Task 1.2: using b + d = 8 and a = 4
1. Formula for b: b = ((b + d)^2 - a^2) / (2(b + d))
2. Substitute b + d = 8 and a = 4: b = (8^2 - 4^2) / (2 * 8) = (64 - 16) / 16 = 48 / 16 = 3
3. Find the diagonal d: d = (b + d) - b = 8 - 3 = 5
We also considered using a + b and ab, and a - b and ab, separately. We can convert each into a quadratic equation and solve for both variables. In both cases we take a to be the longer side, and since ab = 12, we can write b = 12/a.
Task 2.1: using a + b = 7 and A = 12
a + 12/a = 7 => a^2 - 7a + 12 = 0 => (a - 3)(a - 4) = 0.
Since a is the longer side, a = 4, and therefore b = 3.
Task 2.2: using a - b = 1 and A = 12
a - 12/a = 1 => a^2 - a - 12 = 0 => (a - 4)(a + 3) = 0.
A side length must be positive, so a = 4, and therefore b = 3.
In both cases, the Pythagorean theorem gives the diagonal: d = sqrt(a^2 + b^2) = sqrt(16 + 9) = 5.
The Babylonian Method (Part b)
The Babylonians approached this geometrically, using a "cut-and-paste" method. They did not have our algebraic notation, but they understood the relationship between a rectangle's sides and its area. The key identity they used was:
(a + b)^2 - 4A = (a - b)^2.
This identity links the sum, the difference and the area, so knowing the area and either the sum or the difference gives us the other one. Again, there are two approaches.
Approach 1: using a + b = 7 and A = 12
The Babylonians would:
1. Square the sum: (a + b)^2 = 7^2 = 49
2. Multiply the area by 4: 4A = 4 * 12 = 48
3. Subtract: 49 - 48 = 1
4. Take the square root: sqrt(1) = 1, which is a - b
Approach 2: using a - b = 1 and A = 12
The Babylonians would:
1. Square the difference: (a - b)^2 = 1^2 = 1
2. Multiply the area by 4: 4A = 4 * 12 = 48
3. Add: 1 + 48 = 49
4. Take the square root: sqrt(49) = 7, which is a + b
Finding the sides and the diagonal
Either way, they now have both the sum (a + b = 7) and the difference (a - b = 1). To find a and b, they would:
· Add the sum and difference: 7 + 1 = 8, then halve: a = 4
· Subtract the difference from the sum: 7 - 1 = 6, then halve: b = 3
For the diagonal, they used the rule we now call the Pythagorean theorem, d^2 = a^2 + b^2 = 16 + 9 = 25, so d = 5.
This method is geometric at its core. The Babylonians would have visualized a square of side a + b, cut it into pieces, and rearranged them to see that the remaining area after removing four copies of the rectangle is exactly the square of the difference between the sides. It is essentially "completing the square" in a physical, visual way.
Why This Matters
What strikes me is that the Babylonians were solving what we now call quadratic equations, but they did it without symbolic algebra. Their method was rhetorical and geometric: they described steps in words and manipulated mental or physical diagrams. The identity
(a + b)^2 - 4ab = (a - b)^2
is the same one we use today when we solve a quadratic by completing the square, but they arrived at it through a completely different conceptual route.
Extension
As an extension, we asked: what happens if the rectangle is not a 3:4:5 triangle? Suppose a = 5, b = 12. Then a + b = 17, A = 60, and d = sqrt(5^2 + 12^2) = 13. Using the Babylonian identity:
(a + b)^2 - 4A = 17^2 - 240 = 289 - 240 = 49.
sqrt(49) = 7 = a - b.
Then
a = (17 + 7) / 2 = 12, b = (17 - 7) / 2 = 5.
The method works for any rectangle, not just the 3:4:5 case. This shows the power of the Babylonian approach: it is a general algorithm disguised as a geometric procedure.
We also did another extension in terms of coming up with a relationship between the diagonal and the sides of the rectangle. This time we took the 7, 24, 25 triangle and tried to find a similar relation. Just like the Babylonians represented the relationship between the diagonal and the sides of a rectangle by linear equations, we tried finding a similar relation for the 7, 24, 25 triangle, with a = 7, b = 24 and d = 25.
Then we can try to find the ratios for the required relationships:
25 = 7/x + 24, 25 = 24/y + 7.
If we solve these, we get x = 7 and y = 4/3. Therefore another presentation of our triangle becomes
d = a/7 + b and d = 3b/4 + a.
We discovered that any rectangle can be represented by the linear relations between its diagonal and sides if we can figure out the ratios linked to the sides.
Reflection
Working on this problem made me appreciate how much of our modern algebra is a translation of older geometric thinking. The Babylonians did not have variables, but they had a deep understanding of how areas and sides relate. Their "cut-and-paste" method is not just a historical curiosity, it is a different way of thinking about the same mathematical truth. As a future teacher, I want to bring this kind of historical perspective into my classroom. It helps students see that mathematics is not a fixed set of rules handed down from on high, but a human activity that has been done in many different ways across cultures and time periods.
Comments
Post a Comment